>What’s the goal, really?

>As many of you know, our family is being held up in a bureaucratic snare. A trap, a mill…call it what you will. We are coming to think of new terms for it. We will admit, we are frustrated.

We are receiving the run around, ever so politely expressed, but that is what it is. Our inquiries, indeed, the inquiries from senator’s offices even, are being punted back and forth like a football: “We are not in charge of that.” “They oversee this decision.” “That would be the __(fill in the blank: CDC, State Dept, Health and Human Services)_____ domain.”

And so it goes, no one wants to own this, no one wants to really look at it and see what is being said.
And really, we have decided, that no one really wants to look at what is not being said.

So we will. It is not politically correct. I don’t care anymore.
Everyone has said, “It’s not personal, please understand.”
I beg to differ.
It is very much personal, and I don’t understand.
Not at all. Or, actually, I think, we do all too well.

Let me back up. This is the quick summary of the trap: The US CDC has determined to put in place screening measures for all immigrants for tuberculosis. This sounds like a reasonable and reasoned, thoughtful measure. Until you start examining the data. And you realize that most first world countries do not do this, rather, they screen immigrants once they have arrived. And then, if needed, they treat them.

However, our country has decided that the rates of TB have risen enough that they need to do something. And so they have put in place sweeping protocols to screen for tb. Our country has decided to screen immigrants before they arrive on our shores. These are called the 2007 technical instructions. The problem is, these do not outline what to do if a person already HAD tb, and had already been treated. [The 2008 technical instructions for immigrants already in the US expand on the 2007 and they point out that any person who has already been treated, does not need screening, and in fact, may travel freely.] Therefore, any person wishing to come to the U.S. must have a clear skin test, or chest xray or 8 week sputum culture. Period. That sounds reasonable, doesn’t it?

Does it?

What is this really?
Dare I suggest, this is a case of “other.”
Us. Them.
We are here safe and sound in our country. I believe this is a protective measure, but misplaced. I love my country, don’t get me wrong. But ‘they’ are there, and we don’t know what ‘they’ have that might hurt us. And so ‘they’ have to be screened, and kept there until we are sure ‘they’ are “ok,” right? Right?

Do they? What’s the goal? What does that mean?
Is this a measure to lower the levels of TB in our country, only? Is it a measure to lower the levels of TB in other countries? Or is it to keep out risk, or those who are “other?” Is this a question of comfort? Are our levels of comfort being challenged? Well, I think so. This screening is not being done, for instance, on European immigrants, nor Chinese, nor East Indian.

Should children, any of them, of American families, be swept under this measure?

The reason I question all this is because this policy is being applied to kids, without seeing them as individuals, each unique. Kids. It is not being applied foreign temporary workers, not students, not most of the immigrants who arrive on our shores: adults who can easily slip into the system and disappear. This policy, in our particular case and others too, is being applied in broad sweeping strokes to kids. Our kids. Our Ethiopian kids.

Hmm. Look closely. Who are “they?” Are they dangerous to us? Really? Is their goal to come into the country and infect us all? Or to milk the system and our resources? I don’t think so. These kids have one goal: find a family. Find a safe place and a home. That’s it. Do we need to think of these kids as a threat somehow to us? Um, no. Are we at risk from them, these children, really, are we? No. The data supports that. Coffeedoc is more than happy to provide it to anyone interested. The CDC should be too.

This is Christmas dinner at the government orphanage where my daughter lived. This is what
they had as a special celebration feast. Hard to get better, if you DO have tb or any illness on that diet, don’t ya think?

If we were really screening for TB as a matter of compassion and concern for health, wouldn’t the answer be that if you found TB, you would bring that kid home to their family so they could be treated swiftly? Really? Or is it better to leave that child who has a family here, there, alone, sick and scared where they can’t even get the proper nutrition to support the medicine?

We have been told that the CDC is trying to keep our communities, our family, the population at large, ‘safe’ from infection. Um, really? Because on that plane coming home, it’s almost exclusively a population that has been walking around being exposed to all sorts of viruses and infections, utterly unknown in type or quantity. How does letting a child who has already completed treatment for TB keep that community ‘safe?’

I know. You are rolling your eyes, thinking, “she’s on a rant.” Maybe.
But I am tired of this.
This is a stigma.
There is a stigma against scary words and labels: “HIV+” “TB” “Immigrant” “Virus.”
I’m tired of the stigma, of wondering if I can say that my daughter had TB.
Well, she did.
My daughter had TB. She was treated for it, successfully.
She’s over it now.
But they won’t let her come home, because of arbitrary, political, well meaning but misapplied protocols.

But look closely, just below. These aren’t adults. These are children. Our children. This is their Christmas dinner, again. Do they look like something we should fear, somehow?
Are they, really, “other?”
So, I am asking again. What’s the goal, really?
Is it to help with compassion, to help find and treat a treatable disease? Is it to help lower the rates of this worldwide, as the world leader our country is and should be? Is it to help these children be united with a family? Or is it, to somehow attempt to protect, ineffectively, “us.” I’m asking. What’s the goal?

10 thoughts on “>What’s the goal, really?

  1. >As usuall you hit the nail on the head – and I am given to understand that young children can’t even pass the active form of TB because they can’t cough hard enough – and yet numbers of them wait long extra months because of a label that makes some people frightened. It breaks my heart – and I am sure that it breaks God’s heart too.

  2. >Great Post Coffee Mom 🙂 So true and so frustrating!! Praying for her sweet heart to understand…Is she aware of “what’s” going on?? kristi

  3. >As always you have articulated what is in your heart and mind so clearly. I appreciate the perspective that you have brought to this and I am complete agreement with you. We continue to pray fervently for God’s Will and for M to come home very soon.The Darlings

  4. >Very well composed post. You certainly don’t need to apologize for “ranting”. ranting is necessary from time to time to convey the depth of what you need to say. My mother always tests positive for TB. Chest x-ray always shows she is clear. She is an immigrant – from England. She is able to come and go as she pleases. So I agree – what’s the goal here?

  5. >Coffeemom,Are you saying that current US law does not allow an Ethiopian child who’s been successfully treated for TB to come to here and be united with his or her parents? If so, many more PAPs should have great cause for concern, should they not?Do these bureaucrats and politicians you’re contacting get how ridiculous this is? And wrong-headed? Someone made and passed this rule, and someone can surely alter it. I’ll be praying you can find the right people to help you navigate the insane bureaucracy and bring your daughter home to you where she belongs.

  6. >I am so sorry you guys are stuck in the middle of all of this…and hopefully it will get sorted out soon!(By the way, when I immigrated to the US from Norway in 2004, I did have to show proof of TB status, which since we get the BCG in Norway included a chest x-ray. Taken by the one x-ray clinic certified to take such pictures, and followed-up with a doctor’s visit to the one doctor in the country who was allowed to clear me for immigration, and draw blood for the HIV test etc…Thankfully I was very much in love with my husband and decided all the hassle was worth it…:-)

  7. >Zoe,I’m saying that the US CDC is not allowing a child who’s been successfully treated for TB to come into the US until after an 8 week culture is clear. It’s not a law. It is a policy. It is a policy to screen for unknown tb status. It does not accomodate treated patients and therefore all the children are treated as unknown and are screened.This has a greater impact on the PAP’s of HIV+ kids. THere are many more of them than Post TB kids…and they are required to do the same screening too. No exceptions. This policy is not to the benefit of the children, or the families, or the other children around them, or even our US population. It is a blanket policy that needs reworked.IF we knew the someone who could alter it, we’d be in contact with them. WE have not found them yet, as this will almost surely take legislation to change. So, support EACH….that’s the best hope for change. Not soon, but critical important change.Thanks for the comment and the prayers!!!M

  8. >Michelle,My heart is just breaking for your daughter and her precious family waiting. Two of my daughters tested positive for TB. This test was not completed until my daughters were home in the U.S. You are correct, China does not screen for TB, or did not in 2006, 2004 and 2001. My rant? TB is treatable, curable!! We in the U.S. know this. It enrages me that children in other countries do not have the medical benefits that should be afforded them. I cry when I read your daughter has scar damage to her lungs, TB is treatable. The real tragedy is that your daughter did not have access to medical treatment. Why does our country want to punish the children who had no control over any of this mess. Jesus would welcome all the children, and, honestly young or old, we all are His children. I am sorry your family is suffering through this wait. But, I believe God has something BIG planned for your daughter and her family!! If we as families can begin to enlighten even one other person/family to the way children/adults in other countries are forced to live then God is glorified!! I just cry out when I know God saved my daughters lives, if they were still in China, they would be dealing with full blown TB(which, per our physician still is very treatable). What are we as a Church, we as the Body of Christ, we as okay…let’s just go simple here….we as a nation waiting for? We are not the “chosen” ones to just live a secure germ free life. We are to walk boldly into our day and reach, touch, share love on our Brothers and Sisters in Christ. I am crying out to God to hear your prayers, our prayers for your daughter, but, also trusting Him that He will be glorified through yet another Miraculous journey to your daughter.Thank you for letting me share my personal thoughts. TB weighs so very heavy in my heart and family. Children literally are suffering and dying from this disease, and, we as a country, with thoroughly educated, skilled and qualified Doctors, we know this is a disease of treatment and CURE(which your daughter has been blessed to have received treatment alread), not denial, not of unwelcoming the child! ARGGGHHH!!!Lifting you and your sweet daughter up today!!! Please Father in Heaven bring this sweet girl home to her family.


Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s